A “Disco” holo Charizard graded CGC Pristine 10 has become the seventh highest-selling CGC-certified trading card on Fanatics Collect’s auction platform, taking the spot only one month after the previous record holder. The rarity is just one of the thousands of CGC-certified TCGs, sports cards and non-sports cards that were sold through Fanatics Collect marketplace in May 2025.
The Charizard, Pokémon (1999) “Disco” Holo Test Print graded CGC Pristine 10 realized $90,000 on May 22, at the end of Fanatics Collect’s May Premium Auction. As of June 2025, this Pristine 10 “Disco” Holo Charizard is the highest-graded example in the CGC Cards Population Report. As Wizards of the Coast was preparing to release the Base Set of the Pokémon TCG, they started experimenting with different holofoil patterns to use on cards. Though the “Disco” holofoil pattern wasn’t used in the official release, some test prints have gotten into the hands of the public. CGC Cards has only certified 11 “Disco” Holo Charizard cards as of June 2025.
Additionally, a Gengar, Pokémon (2003) Skyridge Holo graded CGC Pristine 10 realized $11,400 on May 11. Gengar is right up there with the likes of Charizard and Pikachu in popularity, which makes many of Gengar’s more vintage cards very valuable to collectors. This Skyridge Gengar is one of only 10 examples graded CGC Pristine 10, according to the CGC Cards Population Report.
Meanwhile, hundreds of CGC-certified sports cards were sold through Fanatics Collect in May as well, with the top highlight being a rare football card from the 1990s that is numbered to only 50 ever made of one of the greatest running backs in NFL history. A 1998 Metal Universe #42 Emmitt Smith - Precious Metal Gems graded CGC 7 realized $15,600 on May 22.
Precious Metal Gems (PMGs) are well-known as one of the rarest cards of the 1990s. PMGs were initially inserted into Metal Universe football sets in 1997 (with print runs of 150), however, the 1998 PMGs were reduced to only 50 cards made. Considering the scarcity of the cards and that PMGs were also known for having surface blemishes and edge wear, this card graded CGC 7 is even more uncommon, as it stands alone in the CGC Cards Population Report.
Another sports highlight from May's Fanatics Collect sales was a one-of-one SuperFractor of arguably the most popular pitcher in baseball right now: Paul Skenes. A 2024 Topps Gilded Collection God Storm #GS-3 Paul Skenes - SuperFractor certified CGC Authentic realized $12,600 on May 4. It gets no rarer than a SuperFractor, and with Skenes being one of the hottest commodities in baseball card collecting today, there are few issues that are more coveted than his one-of-one gems. One of the MLB's youngest stars at only 23 years old, he currently ranks in the Top 10 in strikeouts and ERA this season. As one of the most sought-after players in modern collecting, it's no surprise Skenes' rarest cards are fetching premium prices at auction.
Other recent TCG and non-sports cards sales highlights included:
a Charizard, Pokémon (1999) Base Set Shadowless Holo graded CGC 9.5 that realized $10,375 on May 7
a Bilingual Exeggutor, Pokémon (1999) Japanese Tropical Mega Battle Participation Prize graded CGC Gem Mint 10 that realized $9,750 on May 22
a Chansey, Pokémon (1999) “Disco” Holo Test Print graded CGC Gem Mint 10 that realized $9,450 on May 22
a Charizard, Pokémon (2002) Legendary Collection Reverse Holo graded CGC Gem Mint 10 that realized $7,800
a Shining Magikarp, Pokémon (2000) Japanese Awakening Legends Holo graded CGC Pristine 10 that realized $6,600 on May 4
Other recent sports card sales highlights included:
a 2020 Panini National Treasures Rooke Patch Autographs #156 Joe Burrow - Holo Silver certified CGC Authentic that realized $10,650 on May 22
a 2018 Topps Triple Threads Autographed Relic Combos #ARC-AMS Albert Pujols/Mike Trout/Shohei Ohtani - Wood certified CGC Authentic that realized $10,200 on May 22
a 2024 Topps Chrome Dual Autographs #DA-QB Caleb Williams/Jayden Daniels - SuperFractor certified CGC Authentic that realized $8,700 on May 18
a 2023-24 Topps Inception UEFA CC Succession Autographs #SA-LY Lamine Yamal - Orange certified CGC Authentic that realized $6,600 on May 18
a 1989-90 Hoops #200 Michael Jordan graded CGC 9, with an autograph graded JSA 10 that realized $5,640 on May 4
Notable Upcoming Fanatics Collect Sales
Fanatics Collect continues to offer CGC-certified cards in their weekly, fixed and premium auction formats. One of the sports highlights available in June is a 2022-23 Panini Origins Rookie Jersey Autographs #RJA-PBC Paolo Banchero graded CGC 9, with an autograph graded CGC 10. As one of the young stars of the NBA, Banchero became an immediate focal point to build around after the Orlando Magic selected him with the No. 1 overall pick in the 2022 NBA Draft. This season, the 22-year-old forward led Orlando per game in minutes, points, rebounds and free throws made. Although Banchero led the Magic to the playoffs once again this year, another early exit has the team hoping for a deeper run in the postseason going forward.
Other sports cards in the upcoming May auctions include:
a 1984 Panini F1 Grand Prix Scratch N' Play Ayrton Senna Toleman-Hart TG183 graded CGC 7
a 2000 Bowman #236 Tom Brady - Altered certified CGC Authentic
a 2024 Donruss Optic #201 Caleb Williams - Aqua certified CGC Authentic
a 2024 Bowman Draft Chrome Prospect Autographs #CPA-JC Jac Caglianone certified CGC Authentic
Other TCG and non-sports cards in the upcoming June auctions include:
an Ooyama’s Pikachu, Pokémon (1998) Japanese Vending Series 3 graded CGC Pristine 10
a Charizard EX, Pokémon (2016) Japanese Expansion 20th Anniversary 1st Edition graded CGC Pristine 10
a Mew, Pokémon (2001) Southern Islands Reverse Holo graded CGC Gem Mint 10
Sell Your CGC-certified Cards on Fanatics Collect!
The Fanatics Collect marketplace connects dealers and collectors through fixed-price listings, auctions and a myriad of tools and features, all in one app. Fanatics Collect has partnered with CGC to provide a streamlined pathway to grading and selling, which is accessed via an online submission process through Fanatics Collect's website and managed through the Fanatics Collect vault. For more information about Fanatics Collect, click here.
Cards sent to CGC receive priority grading and encapsulation through its third-party grading service for sports cards. Graded cards are returned to Fanatics Collect and immediately added to their Auction Builder Curation Algorithm process, which optimizes cards for sale in upcoming Fanatics Collect Weekly Sunday Auctions.
For more information about this program, go here.
Prices realized include buyer’s premium.