Sports Illustrated has been a cornerstone of American sports journalism since its debut in 1954, chronicling iconic moments across decades, from historic championships to groundbreaking athlete profiles. When an athlete graces the cover of SI, it is a coveted milestone, placing an athlete among the most elite players of their sport. For more than 70 years, sports fans have collected SI magazines, and in 2004, CGC launched its magazine grading and encapsulation service. Earlier this summer, CGC debuted officially licensed Sports Illustrated certification labels for Sports Illustrated magazines and SI Kids sports cards, offering fans another way to distinguish their collections.
Since the earliest years of the magazine, Sports Illustrated has featured many of the greatest NHL players across multiple generations. From Gordie Howe and Bobby Orr to Wayne Gretzky and Sidney Crosby, the NHL's most dominant players have all made an appearance on the cover of the popular sports magazine. Hockey collectors are a small but devoted group, and the key SI covers below are actively pursued in nice condition without mailing labels:
1) Wayne Gretzky “The Great Gretzky” - 10/12/81

Gretzky is both the most famous and greatest hockey player of all time, and this is his first Sports Illustrated cover. Wayne was (as the cover claimed) the “Best Player in the NHL” at the tender age of 20, and he would remain so throughout the 1980s, winning the Hart Trophy as league MVP every year but one. Because the dramatic orange cover of this issue actually folds in short of the right edge, wear will often show first on the silver first page, which peeks out from under the cover.
2) Bobby Orr “Hockey's Wildest Season” - 12/11/67

Orr was just 19 years old when he appeared for the first time on this Sports Illustrated cover. Like Gretzky, Orr was a prodigy who had been establishing his legend in junior hockey leagues since the age of five. Over an injury-shortened career with the Bruins, Orr would change the pace of play in the NHL and enter the Boston sports pantheon alongside Bill Russell and Ted Williams (later to be joined by Larry Bird).
3) US Olympic Team Beats USSR - 3/3/80

This cover captures the “Miracle on Ice” victory of the Americans over the Soviets in the Lake Placid 1980 Winter Olympics. SI editors smartly included no text on the cover, as everyone knew the story. This issue isn't particularly rare, even as a newsstand edition, because many collectors set aside a copy in mint condition. Demand is even higher, however, as the cover demonstrates national pride even for non-hockey fans. Collectors from Boston to Los Angeles can all enjoy and treasure this issue, which makes it the most likely of all the magazines on this list to be framed on a wall.
4) Gordie Howe and Ted Lindsay "Red-Hot Red Wings" - 3/18/57

Gordie Howe's first cover also featured his linemate and fellow Hall of Famer Ted Lindsay, an undersized left wing who teamed with Howe to capture four Stanley Cups for the Detroit Red Wings in the 1950s. Howe was considered the greatest offensive player in history before Gretzky, but as his career continued, he became known just as much for his freakish longevity as for the many scoring records he held.
Howe played through the 1960s in the NHL, winning his sixth scoring title in 1963. He later played six seasons in the World Hockey Association in the 1970s, skating alongside his two sons. Gordie then rejoined the NHL for a final season in 1979-80, retiring at the remarkable age of 52. He played in All-Star games in five different decades, and he became the ultimate symbol of team-sport performance at advanced ages. Collectors looking to celebrate the amazing length of Howe's career may want to pair this issue with his 1/21/80 cover, “Hockey's Ageless Wonder.”
5) Bobby Orr "Sportsman of the Year" - 12/21/70

Orr's impact on the game of hockey was never more obvious than in the 1969-70 season, when he led the league in scoring (the only time a defenseman has ever done so) and led the Boston Bruins to their first Stanley Cup since 1941. For these achievements, and for changing the role of the NHL defenseman, Orr was the first hockey player ever named Sportsman of the Year by Sports Illustrated.
6) Wayne Gretzky "Sportsman of the Year" - 12/27/82

Gretzky's third SI cover was the only other time a single hockey player was named Sportsman of the Year, and it honored him for his astonishing dominance of the NHL. In 1981-82, Gretzky scored 92 goals, a record that still stands, but his Edmonton Oilers lost the Stanley Cup finals to the New York Islanders. The beginning of the Edmonton dynasty would have to wait until the next year; Gretzky led the Oilers to Stanley Cup championships in '84, '85, '87, and '88.
7) Jean Beliveau “Montreal Hockey” - 1/23/56

Beliveau is one of the greatest players and winners in the history of the NHL, and this cover is significant for several reasons. Beliveau ranks second only to Howe among the top centers of the early years of the league. 1956 was his greatest individual season, as he won both the scoring title and Most Valuable Player honors. But even more impressive than his statistics (including 507 career NHL goals) are his credentials as one of the sport's greatest champions.
Beliveau played for 10 Stanley Cup-winning Canadian teams during the years 1956-1971, and he was team captain of this greatest dynasty in hockey history for his final 10 years. He left the rink as a champion, and he then joined the Montreal executive team to help the team to an additional seven titles. His name therefore appears on the Stanley Cup a record 17 times. If that's not enough to convince you of the collectability of this attractive portrait cover, there's this: it's also the first time SI ever featured hockey on the cover.
8) Mario Lemieux "As Great as Gretzky?" - 2/6/89

Yes, Super Mario really was so good that SI wondered whether he could surpass Wayne Gretzky. In 1988-89, Lemieux scored 85 goals and registered 199 points in 76 games, numbers which can stand proudly next to Gretzky's greatest seasons. Injuries ultimately prevented Lemieux from achieving as many great seasons as his predecessor, but his greatness is undisputed. Never has such a large player (6'4”, 235 pounds) exhibited such tremendous skating, shooting, and puck-handling skills. Lemieux's popularity is magnified by the fact that he played his entire NHL career with the Pittsburgh Penguins, and after retirement he bought the team, saved them from moving, and led them to three more championships with Sidney Crosby on the ice.
9) Sidney Crosby "The Kid and The Cup" - 6/22/09

This regional issue featured the best player in the game at the time celebrating his first Stanley Cup. Like the other stars on this list, Crosby made a major impact on the game at a very young age – he is only 21 years old on this cover. Although not technically his first SI cover (Crosby was surrounded by Detroit Red Wings on the 6/8/09 cover), this is the most popular of his appearances. It's a classic victory pose that could occupy the center of any Pittsburgh Penguins display or collection. It's also fairly rare, since most of the country received the Kobe Bryant cover on this issue.
10) Bobby Hull "Breakaway for the Record" - 1/25/65

Such a great player, such ugly SI covers. Bobby Hull was featured on the cover of Sports Illustrated five times from 1960 to 1972, but this is the only one that a Chicago Blackhawks fan can display with pride. Hull's first cover, from 1960, features primitive artwork that looks like a rough draft from a sketching class. In 1964, his body is obscured by an opponent in a shot that would never make a modern SI cover, and in 1968 the cover shot makes him look 49 years old, not 29. The 1972 cover won't win many fans, as it features Bobby in a Blackhawks uniform even though he would never play another game for them (he joined the upstart WHA for the 1972-73 season).
That leaves us with only this 1965 cover, with its colorful and attractive illustration of the “Golden Jet” in action. Hull was the greatest scorer in the game and was a season away from setting a goals record of 54; three years later he would advance his own record to 58. Hull's legacy has been slightly dimmed by the fact that his seasonal records were overwhelmed by the deluge of scoring in the much different game of the 1980s and 1990s (for example, Bobby's son Brett scored 86 goals in the 1990-91 season), and his career NHL numbers of course don't include the 303 goals he scored in the WHA. But Bobby Hull is remembered by those who saw him as the most dominating scorer of his era, the Mickey Mantle of hockey with great speed and power.
Mark Humphries has been reading Sports Illustrated since 1977, when a neighbor began giving second-hand copies to the sports-obsessed 10-year-old. When the 1978 Swimsuit Issue arrived, the content was first screened by his mother. Mark survived the trauma of viewing Cheryl Tiegs in her famous fishnet suit and later became a subscriber and collector of SI. In 2002, following the lead of CGC in comics, he created and marketed the first capsule for graded magazines. Mark holds a BA in history and an MS in industrial engineering from Stanford University, and an MBA in finance from Wharton.
This is a guest article. The thoughts and opinions in this piece are those of their author and are not necessarily the thoughts of the Certified Collectibles Group.
